HEARTY SQUIRREL FOOD COOP
  • About Us
  • Stall
  • Orders
  • Suppliers
  • Resources
    • Food Places
    • Recipes
    • Zines
    • Articles
  • Get Involved
    • Events
  • About Us
  • Stall
  • Orders
  • Suppliers
  • Resources
    • Food Places
    • Recipes
    • Zines
    • Articles
  • Get Involved
    • Events

THE POLITICS BEHIND THE FOOD WE EAT

BIlly Wheeler – may 2025​
You might have noticed the term ‘ultra-processed foods’ (UPFs) creeping into the vernacular in recent years. But what actually are UPFs – and why the sudden surge in interest?  

​Like a lot of people, my curiosity spiked after reading the 2023 book Ultra-Processed People, in which Dr Chris van Tulleken – known to the culturally attuned as co-presenter of CBBC’s Operation Ouch! – unpacks the concept. In doing so, he reveals the overwhelming power of large corporations in shaping the food system. 

Defining UPF 

As the book explains, UPFs are defined using the ‘Nova’ scale – a system developed in the 2010s by Brazilian epidemiologist Carlos Montiero, which classifies food into four groups. 

First are unprocessed or minimally processed foods – natural items like vegetables, meat, nuts, eggs and milk, as well as those with minimal alteration, such as butter, yoghurt and cheese. 

Second are processed culinary ingredients – substances extracted from group one foods through simple processes, like pressed oils or ground spices, as well as naturally occurring products like honey. 

The third category – processed foods – are made by combining ingredients from groups one and two. Cooking has always involved some degree of processing – cutting, boiling, frying, and mixing ingredients. Foods in this group form the basis of culinary culture around the world. 

Finally – and here lies the central subject of van Tulleken’s book – are UPFs. Unlike with the first three groups, which reflect how humans have prepared food for millennia, UPFs rely on industrial processes and are designed for profitability. While such products have existed since the advent of industrial technology, the deregulation and globalisation of food markets from the 1980s have driven their rapid proliferation.  
 
The Purpose of UPF 

There are endless ways to categorise food, and dietary fads that elevate certain foods while demonising others come and go. Arguably, what makes the Nova classification different is that it incorporates a political analysis into the nutrition debate.  

Specifically, it highlights how the pursuit of profit, rather than food’s original purpose of nourishment, has allowed UPFs to dominate our diets, now accounting for over half of the calories consumed in the UK. 

To achieve this dominance, companies have replaced real ingredients with cheaper alternatives, mostly at the expense of nutritional value. Over decades, this process has reshaped the food landscape, diminishing the availability and accessibility of foods from groups 1-3 on the Nova scale. 

Next time you’re in the supermarket, look at the ingredients on the back of many household staples. What once might have been recognisable components are now a dizzying list of additives – artificial colourings, emulsifiers, gums, preservatives, and other compounds – more reminiscent of a chemistry textbook than a traditional recipe. 

There is growing evidence that this kind of processing – by making food hyper-palatable and less satiating – drives overconsumption and generates significant costs for society.

The Trouble with Individual Choice 

The supposed cheapness of UPFs masks the reality that their consumption leads to adverse health and environmental outcomes. Failure to curb our intake will impose enduring costs onto the NHS, which is already under immense pressures from an ageing population.  

A range of factors also mean that high UPF consumption restricts our capacity to decarbonise the global economy. 

From the point of production, many UPF products rely on vast quantities of cheap palm oil or other monoculture crops that drive deforestation. Add to this the emissions from global transportation, as well as the industrial processing that consumes large amounts of water and energy, and the increased use of plastic packaging – the environmental toll is staggering. 

With the negative consequences of UPFs becoming increasingly clear, the question is why have most societies so far failed to limit their consumption. 

A key problem is that responsibility for food choices is often individualised – both in our culture and in the policies pursued by governments.  

Two Factors Entrenching UPF 

An individualised framing creates two key barriers that hinder a broader shift towards minimally processed diets. 

The first is financial. Avoiding UPFs in 2025 requires not only monk-like discipline, but also a level of privilege – only the better-off can afford a diet based primarily on minimally processed foods. Stagnating wages and the cost of living crisis mean that for many, especially parents with less time, the option of buying more expensive foods that contain whole, recognisable ingredients simply is not viable. The Food Foundation’s 2025 report found that following the government’s recommended Eatwell guidelines requires the poorest fifth of households with children to spend 70% of their disposable income on food – compared to just 12% for those in the highest income quintile.  

The second barrier is cultural. As UPFs have come to replace traditional diets, food companies have undermined something deeply cultural – the idea of meals as shared experiences, made from scratch, with recipes and traditions passed down through generations.  

​Fixing the Food System 

Reimagining the food system is no easy feat – it requires confronting powerful corporate interests and our own cultural norms. 

Regulating UPFs becomes challenging when corporations relentlessly lobby governments to water down effective regulations – a tactic that, as The Guardian recently reported, has influenced UK policy. It is common for food corporations to harness opposition to the so-called ‘nanny state’ to constrict regulations that might stifle their profits.  

Because this is a question of inequality and injustice, calls for a redistributive wealth system could help widen access to healthy and more sustainable food, along with the numerous other health benefits that would follow. 
Focusing on the cultural aspect of food, another part of the solution is to reclaim the joy and community UPFs have eroded – by sharing meals and knowledge about food.  

This is where organisations like the Hearty Squirrel come in, demonstrating that it is possible to organise around food in the pursuit of access to local, seasonal and affordable produce.  

Initiatives like the monthly meal show that, with organisation, it is possible to provide nourishing, healthy, and – crucially – affordable food to a large group. Similar projects, such as public diners, are bringing this ethos to the wider Edinburgh community – beyond the student bubble. 
​

Challenging the dominance of UPFs in our food system requires both stronger government regulation and the cultivation of community-based alternatives. The politics behind what we eat shape the choices available to us – not just as consumers, but as citizens. There is no reason we should not demand policies that prioritise health, equity, and the rebuilding of communal food culture. 
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.